Category Archives: Experiential Learning

Abundance vs scarcity

Life is filled with scarcity and abundance at the same time. Whichever view we take will impact our own course through life.  Are you a scarcity thinker, or full of abundance everywhere?

I’d like to drill down into this, because lately they’ve been impacting WinSol’s Learning Center future:  whether we’ll live a world of plenty & free energy, or in an apocalypse of scarcity where we’re scourging for every last BTU.

Back to the future

First, let’s take a trip back to the 70’s… That’s when the first big modern public standoff  took place between abundance and scarcity mindsets:   Paul Erlich made a bet in 1980 on the impending scarcity of materials (partially based on his books ‘population bomb & limits to growth’ ).  Simon challenged Ehrlich to choose any raw material he wanted and a date more than a year away, and he would wager on the inflation-adjusted prices decreasing as opposed to increasing.

Ehrlich chose copper, chromium, nickel, tin, and tungsten. The bet was formalized on September 29, 1980, with September 29, 1990 as the payoff date. Ehrlich lost the bet, as all five commodities that were bet on declined in price from 1980 through 1990, the wager period.[1]

I’d like to believe that I am an abundant thinker (without the rose colored glasses) without the utopia of a ‘full-speed ahead’ mentality. But deep down, maybe I’m really a scarcity kinda guy. I still scrounge around for the best deal, hardly leave anything on my plate, and am prone to negative thinking.  Try as I may, having been born into a poor immigrant post WWII family.  Perhaps I am wired to think life is filled and will be filled with scarcity.  The laws of entropy and finite global resources tend to back that view up.

 

I like this definition:  The Scarcity Mentality is limiting. It may seem  like a good plan at first, but over time too much  energy is wasted on conflict, negative thinking, and stifled creativity. On the other hand, the Abundance Mentality is beyond one’s ego.It’s fearless, it’s free, and it’s immune to criticism. It is beneath no one and superior to no one. It is full of magic.

And once I look at this chart of the two mindset’s characteristics, well it becomes way clearer which way I lean. How about you?

Solutions…

My favorite example of everything that’s right with society is when one person lights another’s candle with their own, and the next one, and next… until thousands are lit.  There is nothing lost from each person or their candle, and yet one flame lights thousands of others.  Togetherness, sharing, abundance, beauty, MAGIC.

Gratitude is a powerful enhancer of an abundant mindset.

From Steve Covey to Wayne Dyer to Anthony Robbins and so many more – getting an abundant mindset is a life changer.

On a personal note, I’ve been re-examening my whole life-style choices (something I do every few years – some people call it a vision quest or long retreat) : Why shouldn’t I just get back on the treadmill and live it up? …enjoy the modern luxuries of endless energy, food, water, materials and join the rest of society in its feast of endless luxuries…

It’s really all about scale.  On the long horizon we live in a finite world. There’s only so much of anything and everything. We may have enough oil in the ground to last another hundred years…

And then there’s the famous quip that ‘… we didn’t stop using whale oil to light our street lamps because we ran out of whales…’ the answer being that we discovered natural gas and kerosene.

————————————————-

….under development… stay tuned:….And so today, we can see that electric and hydrogen cars will replace fossil fuel cars, and that instead of an oil peak in supply, the industry today is faced with an oil peak in demand: something Hubbert ………….. did not forsee.

But getting back to the dilemna: whether to live with a scarcity or abudnant world view.

I like to live with the thought that our energy/water/material world is one of increasing scarcity while within my spiritual heart I live with the thought that abundance is everywhere – the universe is one of abundance.

We gotta live within our means.   Wasting a resource is crazy, no matter if it’s plentiful or not. 

Energie Wende

that’s German for ‘Energy Turning’... which is well under way with the utility death-spiral already a reality in Germany, but we have our own ‘energy turning in the USofA’… so here’s annual op-ed on energy:

Exec Sum: It’s time to take a hiatus and chill in our warming planet: it’s all too damn confussing,  as our rubber band has exceeded its stretching limits:  Oil prices will continue to hover between $20-40, coal IS done – fini-  despite trumpian efforts,  wind and solar will continue to enlighten, and the USA will continue to gets its energy ass kicked by Europe and China… we are a laughing stock when it comes to energy policy: cheap oil at any price.  We hardly notice as the world moves on (to renewables).

Between falling oil prices and OPEC’s dysfunction (latest production cut agreement won’t hold long),  trumping around with uncertainty, Paris accords fading, Venezuela’s civil unrest, protesters turning into connected protectors,  fracking getting a pass,  more cars at less MPGs, Tesla’s stock shrinking as marriage to its incestuous cousin is approved, and Gaia keeps turning up the
heat on us frogs, what can I say that’s positive?   Hey – we’re waking up!  slowly but surely we are reaching a tipping point and I’m optimistic that our Big Brains will soon figure out that nature doesn’t really have an opinion and it’s better off without us – any questions?  There’s just one little issue with my optimism: Are we really that smart?  It only took us 5,000 years to put wheels on our luggage! And that was on top of 55,000 years without wheels!  something about chisels?… but I digress…

We have an energy solution right in front of us, but can’t seem to get past bi-partisan morass. Even NRG can’t figure it out… I get tired reading about the troubles in the renewable business… would the pop media wake up and get some balls – please?  Fossil fuels are not only messy, they’re guey, they stink, their supply chain is extremely inefficient (<5%), when they leak they kill, and we’re addicted like a heroin addict.  If you’ve ever driven up to an active fracking development area, you’ll be smelling and seeing methane clouds miles away; or if you’ve been with a wild-catting/leatherneck crew you’ll soon learn the messy business of dozens of 100ft long steel pipes swinging overhead waiting to be launched into the ground to send a diamond drill bit down,down,down (sound like I’ve been there? – yep in the 80’s… they were fracking then too in Oklahoma and I had a front row seat… but the fracking is WAY bigger & messier now).

(Newsflash on a recent Oil discovery: a HUGE – yes a trumpian huge – oil reserve in the Texas Bakken field was just unearthed that’ll keep oil & gas prices low for years more and renewables in the USA fighting for survival.)

renewables are messy...and renewables continue getting a dose of political uncertainty (again, sigh…) but what’s so messy about hooking up two wires to a solar panel, a couple water pipes to a hot water collector, or erecting a steel tower (once) for a wind blade? Compared to ANYTHING in the fossil fuel industry… absolutely nothing! (sing it Edwin Starr…. music tune: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpWmlRNfLck

Here’s an easy solution:  teach a kid how to heat water with a black soda bottle (just put some dark liquid in there and stick it out in the sun), or point out the solar PV panels on rooftops, and maybe even a wind turbine when you’re driving around… but hey! in order to be a teacher, y’all gotta be a good student… so study up and then teach the GOOD stuff to a young-un.

Note: if ya wanna be really cool, do this on the right… super heat a soda can!

——————————————————————

P.S. That’s what the LeLc is all about… FUN and PLAY… and the GREAT TURNING  (WTR)

 

systems thinking & LeLc learning programs

Everything is interconnected.  Yes – and it’s complicated and simple at the same time.  I’ve been there.

With the LeLc (Living Energy Learning Center at WinSol) I’m going to be exploring the simpler side of this interconnectedness.

I spent five years on the complicated side:  (2001-2006) with some of the leading brains in the world from Peter Senge (MiT)and his SoL org and their first Congress in Vienna,  then with Dr. Andrew Ford at Eastern Washington U and his ‘environmental modeling’ work, and Dr. Braungart in Hamburg with his EPEA Cradle-to-Cradle.  I have fond memories of speaking at a Systems Design conference in Bergen, Norway and a ‘moose safari’ in the fjords with a executive friend from Det Norske Veritas in Oslo.

I worked with Peregrine Systems, PowerSim software, and Cisco Systems on developing some pretty advanced complex SD (System Dynamic) models for lease holdings and workplace productivity.  And the result?  Once again (sigh), I was too far ahead of the curve and couldn’t squeeze a profit to keep the business operations going.

But, man did I learn a lot!  Things are complicated and counter-intuitive, and they sure are interconnect
ed!  And it sure was fun teaching it at CSUS’s GBO program on sustainable business practices… carbon bathtub and all.

Fast forward a decade, and now I find myself deeply engaged with Joanna Macy’s WTR work – and trying to figure out how to leverage that for some good.  And by good, I mean RESULTS.  I learned as an auditor for the Senate Baldridge Quality Award, that results are what matters – the rest is mostly marketing (aka window dressing).

So the challenge with the LeLc (Living Energy Learning Center)  will be how to incorporate all of this SD modeling, educational intents, inspiration, ancients’ wisdom, Gaia’s pleadings: calling us to PLEASE STOP this destructive onslaught… into real RESULTS for LeLc attendees that effect real change.

Fast forward to experiental learning.  i think that’s the sweet spot.  All the lecturting, field trips, powerpoint & prezi shows are fine, but figuring out processes and exercises and DEMONSTRATING things in a lab type setting so that people can PLAY with things – that’s my new passion, and that’s where the LeLc (Living Energy Learning Center) is headed.

I ran across this interesting business playwheel (aka mandala? 🙂 about STEM and learning – what do you think?  is it worthwhile  pursuing?  stay tuned…

 

 

…  my opinion:   I think it’s a lot better than Bloom’s taxonomy – but that also has its purpose.  Sometimes I wish permaculture PDC and other programs would have some discipline in putting their learning programs together, rather than just follow some book or concept or brainstorming… but focus on REAL learning methods: like a taxonomy of learning?

stay tuned… now that the LeLc construction is winding down… the REAL thing begins… wheeeeeeeee……

 

WinSol & LeLc update

As of this post, the interior of the LeLc (Living Energy Learning Center) Dome has been painted white, the cupola is finished with 360deg screening.  The openness and acoustics are amazing.  From July 8-30th there will be continuous work parties pouring the 1200sq.ft. earthen plaster floor inside the dome.  This is the first announcement – so if y’all want to help out, please email us (see resource tab).

Here’s a view from the outside of the entire LeLc and interior cupola:

LeLc ext SideView1
LeLc ext SideView1
Dome cupola
Dome cupola

 

 

 

 

Oscillating between the Bay Area, Lost Valley ecoVillage and the hi-Sierra it is all too evident that we are at a great turning point (WTR).   I wonder if this is our last golden age.  If this is our peak – as far as reaping the spoils of Gaia with minimal consequences, and if we are pivot point – either a great unraveling, or a great awakening.  It’s good to be optimistic about the latter, but is it reality?  How can we tell?  Knowledge and science go only so far – in both this unraveling or it’s turning for the good.  It’s really up to each and every single one of us.  And education is the great mediator.  But our universities and K-12 have utterly failed us.  The web provides little alternative.

I don’t know or propose solutions here – just an observation and a call to wake up.  To let go of the numbness, embrace the pain of Gaia.  We are her children and she’s about to get pissed!